800-809-2307
Four Letters. Infinite Potential.
Are You Putting Account Holders First?

Are You Putting Account Holders First?

Focus on consumer protection enforcement may be increasing

 

By Richard Miller, Executive Vice President

 

The shift away from implementing new regulations on financial products and services is welcome news for financial institutions already dealing with other present and emerging challenges this year. But recent signals shed light on possible efforts to strengthen the enforcement of some regulations already in place which protect consumers against unfair products and practices.

 

Earlier this month, the House Committee on Financial Services held a hearing entitled, “Putting Consumers First? A Semi-Annual Review of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau” (CFPB). This was the first of two annual hearings on CFPB activity mandated by the Dodd-Frank Act.

 

During the session, lawmakers questioned CFPB Director Kathy Kraninger on the changes made to existing rules and the significant drop in enforcement on actions that harm consumers. Committee Chairwoman, Congresswoman Maxine Waters (D-CA), re-introduced a discussion draft of the Consumers First Act that she originally filed in 2018. This Act would restore the supervisory and enforcement powers of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB).

 

While this doesn’t definitely signal immediate changes in the regulatory landscape, banks and credit unions should be cautious not to underestimate the importance of regulatory compliance at all times.

 

One area in particular to watch is the uncertainty regarding communication, disclosures and error resolution around the assessment of an overdraft fee for POS transactions that were authorized on good funds but settle after the account balance has been depleted by an intervening transaction that causes there to be insufficient funds to pay the original item (“authorize positive/settle negative" transactions).

 

How a positive swipe becomes a negative experience

From the consumer perspective, when a debit card purchase is approved, an account holder assumes that the transaction is complete. This can occur whether the financial institution uses an “available balance” (which might include disclosed overdraft limits) or a ledger balance to authorize the debit card transaction.

 

But on the processing side of the equation, if a core system doesn’t have the capability to identify authorized items (where no fee is assessed) among the other items presented against the account while the authorized amount is being held from the balance — such as POS debit card transactions that fall below a merchant’s floor limit and don’t require authorization, checks, ACH items and teller transactions — the available balance can be depleted. When this happens, the account holder can be hit with an unexpected overdraft fee because there aren’t enough funds to pay the amount that was authorized on a positive balance.

 

Why this is a compliance problem

According to guidance released by all regulatory agencies since 2015, charging an overdraft fee on an authorized POS transaction in this circumstance is a violation of the Unfair and Deceptive Acts and Practices (UDAP) Rule because the available balance was positive at the time of authorization. Under regulatory guidelines this transaction cannot be assessed a fee at the time of settlement, regardless of the account balance.

 

Failure to address such UDAP policy violations can result in fines, regulatory orders to refund fees, and damage to account holder relationships and reputation if the issue is made public. Keep in mind, negative comments about a bad banking experience can do exponential damage to an institution’s reputation if they go viral on social media.

 

Added legal risk for non-disclosure

What’s more, if an institution hasn’t provided an easy-to-understand explanation of what constitutes an “available balance” in the account, along with clear disclosure about the use of available balance to determine how an account becomes overdrawn, account holders don’t have the information they need to make the best financial decisions.

 

Most legal actions related to POS transaction fees occur because financial institutions did not provide clear disclosure regarding the use of available balance — leaving account holders unaware and uninformed.

 

Awareness is key to maintaining compliance

Authorized POS transactions can’t be identified when an item settles. It is up to an institution’s core processor to distinguish authorized transactions among all of the transactions that impact the available balance and mark them “fee or no fee” when they are authorized.

 

But if the core isn’t able to identify the transactions at the appropriate time— or offers a module that attempts to correct the problem but isn’t consistently reliable —it is the institution’s responsibility to immediately resolve the issue by refunding any fees that are assessed in error as soon as the issue is identified, in order to maintain compliance.

 

Avoid the potential pitfalls of POS transaction fees

As the number of POS debit card transactions continues to increase, maintaining reliable processes, clear disclosures and error resolution regarding fees that are charged due to “authorize positive/settle negative" transactions is increasingly important to avoid potential harm to account holders.

 

Regardless of what’s making news in the regulatory arena, fair and responsible treatment of account holders should be an on-going priority for banks and credit unions. An expert in overdraft solutions can provide the expertise, technology and tools your institution needs to adequately handle any fee and disclosure issues to help you avoid the possibility of regulatory violations and maintain positive performance and service results.

 

 


ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Richard Miller is executive vice president for John M. Floyd & Associates. With a broad base of management experience in community banking he offers great insight on building relationships and improving organizational structure.  Learn more about Richard.

 

ABOUT JOHN M. FLOYD & ASSOCIATES (JMFA)
JMFA is considered one of the most trusted names in the industry helping community banks and credit unions improve their performance and profitability. Whether it’s recovering lost revenue, uncovering savings opportunities, serving your account holders better or offering a 100% compliant overdraft program—JMFA has the right solutions to help you deliver measurable results. We are proud to be a preferred provider among many industry groups. To learn more please contact your local representative or call us at (800) 809-2307.

 

 

100% 12 months 2020 2020 vision 40 years abusive abusiveness Academy account holder account holder retention account holder strategies account holder strategies; growth strategies; account holders accountability Achieve achievements Advancements Advice Agreement alerts analysis Analytics announcement ask the expert Assistance ATM ATMs Attendees attorneys attracting talent auto loans Automation B2B Balance Bank Bank of Pacific Banking banking services banks banks and credit unions batching Benefit best practices board governance board member board of directors Bob Layendecker bottom line branch equipment branch profitability branding Bryan Hanks budget budgets bundling business business culture business environment business practices business processes business strategies calendar career advice Career Goal CARES Act case studies Case Study CDC CEO CEO onboarding certainty CFPB Challenges change charitable Checklist Cher Cheryl Lawson Choose Chris Karstens claim clarity class action class-action lawsuit Classroom clients Cloud Cohron collections CommFirst Federal Credit Union commitment committed Communication communications communities community community banks Community Outreach Referral Program Competition Competitive Complaint Compliance compliance examinations compliance review compliance risks compliant condition conduct Conferences connection Consistency Consistent consultant Consultation consulting Consumer Consumer FInancial Protection Bureau consumer protection Consumer-focused Consumers Contingency Contingency Pricing contingency-based contingency-based fees Contract Contract Analysis Contract Negotiation contract negotiations contract negotiator Contract Optimizer Contract Renegotiations contract review contract staffing Contracts Convenience core processor contracts Cornerstone Credit Union League coronavirus corporate culture corporate governance costs Courtesy Pay COVID-19 CPE credits Credit Card credit card contracts credit card processing credit cards credit report Credit Union Credit Union Vendor Management credit unions crisis Crissandra Fry CSS culture customer customer experience customer service CUVM cyber security Damian Data Data Analytics database Deal debit debit card contracts Debt deceptive Decisions Demand Letters Department of Labor Deposit deposits Development Dick Miller digital directors Disclosed disclosures discounts Discussion Dodd-Frank Act dollars donation Donna Sumrall Dynamic economy Education efficiency studies election Email Emergencies Emergency employed employee employee retention employees EMV migration enforce enforcement Engagement Errors evaluation Evolve executive search Expectations Expense expense management expense reduction expenses Experience Expert expert negotiations expertise Experts expire Facilitators families FastTrack FDIC Federal Reserve Federal Reserve Board fee Feedback fees Financial Financial Institution financial institutions financial services financial stability Financial Worry FinTech Fixed limits Fixed-limit Floyd's Forum Forrester Free Analysis full disclosure Fully Fully Disclosed fully disclosed overdraft program funds Gen Z Generating Income generating leads generation Generation Z Gift global Goals governance government government agencies Grow Gym Halloween Hammond Happiness health hiring HKW Holiday Holidays Houston Area Food Bank Houston Livestock Show and Rodeo HR HR policies Hubur human capital human resources Implementation important Improved improved efficiencies improved results Inc. income income enhancement Industry information technology Innovate Innovative Institution interests internet banking services interview strategies interview tips IT contracts Jackson Jai Jai Darden James Jamone Moore Jan Southern Jennifer Peoples Jennifer Simmons Jim Griffis Jimmy Nguyen JMFA JMFA Academy JMFA clients JMFA News JMFA Next Generation Overdraft Privilege Joe Marsh John Cohron John M. Floyd John M. Floyd & Associates judicial justification Kelli Silvernale NCUA Kelly Flynn Kennedy knowledge law lawsuits Lawyer leaders leadership Learn Learning Legal legal risk legislative lending program Lesson leverage Limit Limits Literacy litigation litigators lives loans local Long Term Long-Term lost revenue Maggie Thompson Maintenance manage Managed management Mark Roe marketing marketplace Mary Soergel Matrix Matrix-based measurable measurable results meeting Member Members Midwest Region Millennial Millennials mindset minimalism minimalist Mississippi Missouri Mobile Banking Model monetary Money Morrison & Foerster Partner mortgages Most Valuable Provider NAFCU NCUA negative balance Negative Settlement Negotiate negotiating contracts negotiator Net Operating Analysis New Decade New Year New Year's Next Generation JMFA Overdraft Privilege NOA Non-Compliant non-disclosed Non-Interest Income NSF NSF fees Obrea Poindexter OCC Officer Oliver Ireland onboarding Online Opportunities Opportunity Opt-In organization Organizational Health Outcomes outsourcing Overdraft overdraft compliance overdraft coverage overdraft fees overdraft practices Overdraft Privilege overdraft privilege program overdraft program Overdraft programs overdraft protection programs Overdraft Protection Service overdraft service overdraft services overdraft strategy overdrafts overdrawn Overspending pandemic Partner partnership Paul McFarland paycheck emergency payday loans Payments Pennsylvania performance personnel physical distancing plan planning Plus4 Credit Union podcast policies Policy POS Positive Swipe practice practices Press Release Privilege Manager CRM proactive procedure process process improvement Processing product profitability Productivity Products Professional Profitability Improvement Program Program Management programs prohibited project staffing Promotions Proposals Provider providers PwC Quality quantity Reactive reality Recruitment Services recruitment strategies reduce expenses refer referral Reg E regional director regulation Regulation E regulations regulators regulatory relationship Relationships remote Renegotiate Renewal Reporting Reputation resolutions Resources Results Retail Retaining Employees Retention Retirement revenue revenue enhancement review Richard Miller risk risks ROI Ron Jennings Roy Roy Seifert Rules Ryan Armstrong Sales Salesforce Satisfaction savings Scrutiny secrets Security senate Senior Relationship Manager service service agreements service contracts service delivery Services Sessions settlement shareholders Sheila Bridges Shopping social distancing Social Events social media Software Solution solutions specialization Spending staff staff development staff spotlight staff training staffing staffing gaps staffing studies staffing study stakeholders standard Statistics stimulus payments Strategic Planning Strategies Strategy streamline Stressful succeed Success success factors Succession plan succession planning Support survey Susan Prell system talent team team members technology technology costs technology upgrades technology utilization temporary staff term Text Third-Party Expert third-party providers third-party vendor contracts third-party vendors threat three Tim Strandquist Time Tools Tracking Trainer training transaction Transparency Transparent Travel Treats trends Trey Martin Trust UDAAP uncertain times unemployment unfair updates Upgrades Value Variable Variable Limits Vendor vendor agreements vendor contract negotiations vendor contracts vendor management services vendor performance vendors video violation volunteer Walker Washington Washington Savings Bank webinar Webinars weeks Westmoreland Community FCU Whitney & Company Wish list women work Workshops YouTube